Professor Young
ENGW_1100_34
October 3 2015
In Jane Anyon's essay, "Social class and the hidden curriculum of work," education is portrayed differently based on different social economical backgrounds. I feel Anyon's position is arguable in today's era. I feel different schools, such as the one's portrayed in Anyon's essay, often teach different curriculum to their students. I agree that the type of school a student attends can affect the future profession, because more specific schools have higher learning standards set for their students. But I also feel, that schools do not offer the same type of curriculum to their students as other schools of different social classes. For example, I have attended Catholic school for majority of my educational experience, and I have been given the privilege of a higher education. But during
my first
year of high school, I decided to attend a local public school, Susan Wagner
High School similar to the working class school described in Anyon's
essay. What surprised me was the difference in curriculum that teachers
gave to their classes. The teachers in Wagner rarely gave tests on the
class material, and when they were reviewing material they quickly went
through topic after topic without vague explanation on how to complete the
assignment. To illustrate, during my first history class of
Wagner
the teacher assigned several DBQ reading assignments during class time had an
expectation and had the expectation that students were aware how to
complete these types of assignments. Moreover, when I stated that I was
unaware what the task was, the professor gave me an attitude and told me
to "read the assignment and simply follow the direction carefully."
Similar to Anyon's description of the working class teacher,"A group of
students 'still didn't get it,' and she made no attempt to explain the concept
of dividing things into groups or to give them manipulables for their own
investigation. Rather, she went over the steps with them again and told them
that they 'needed more practice,'" I found new style of learning
difficult, because I was basically teaching myself the material. While
attending Catholic school I experienced a different approach to learning, the
teachers were more involved with their students and were concerned if their
students didn't not understand the topic that was being taught. Such as Anyon
stated, " There is recognition that cognitive process is involved; 'I want
to make sure you understand what you are doing-so you get it right'," the
students ability is important to the teacher, and the approach of how the
teacher presents the curriculum can truly affect the preparation of the
student's future.
No comments:
Post a Comment